EU Court Rules Malta Golden Passport Illegal – Major Shift for Citizenship-by-Investment in Europe

On this page
  1. What Was the Malta Golden Passport Program?
  2. Why the EU Court Ruled It Illegal
  3. Reactions to the Ruling
  4. Implications for Other Citizenship-by-Investment Programs
  5. What Happens to Existing Malta Golden Passport Holders?
  6. Conclusion: A New Era for Investment-Based Citizenship in Europe

EU Court Declares Malta Golden Passport Illegal in Landmark Ruling

Updated November 2026: Malta has since closed its citizenship-by-investment route. The Maltese Citizenship (Amendment) Act, Act XXI of 2025, published on 24 July 2025, replaced it with a merit-based route, so Malta CBI is no longer available. People who want to live in Malta can still look at work and residence routes, such as a Malta work permit.

On April 29, 2025, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled Malta’s golden passport scheme illegal under EU law. The Court found that Malta had, in effect, been granting EU citizenship in return for payments and investments. Because the judgment interprets EU law, it applies to every other member state too.

What Was the Malta Golden Passport Program?

Malta’s first investor citizenship scheme, the Individual Investor Programme (IIP), was launched in 2013. In 2020 it was replaced by the scheme the court ruled on, citizenship by naturalisation for exceptional services by direct investment, which allowed non-EU nationals to acquire Maltese—and therefore European Union—citizenship by making a substantial financial contribution to the country. Applicants could invest:

  • €600,000 with a 3-year residency

  • Or €750,000 with a 1-year residency

Additionally, a Maltese home (bought for at least €700,000 or rented at €16,000 a year) and a €10,000 donation were required. Though the government claimed the program boosted the economy by over €1.4 billion, critics warned that it undermined the value and integrity of EU citizenship.

Why the EU Court Ruled It Illegal

The Malta golden passport scheme was ruled to be in violation of EU principles because it commodified citizenship, offering it in exchange for money without ensuring a genuine link between the individual and the member state. The court reaffirmed that:

  • EU citizenship should involve shared values, rights, and responsibilities

  • Member states must act in sincere cooperation with EU institutions

  • Citizenship cannot be purely transactional

Reactions to the Ruling

Transparency campaigners and many EU policymakers welcomed the verdict as a defence of what EU citizenship is meant to stand for. Legal experts noted that the court’s interpretation may force other member states with similar schemes to revise or shut them down entirely.

Meanwhile, some Maltese officials criticized the ruling, arguing it was politically motivated. Malta said it would comply, and on 24 July 2025 it published the Maltese Citizenship (Amendment) Act (Act XXI of 2025), which ended citizenship by direct investment and replaced it with a merit-based route for exceptional services.

Implications for Other Citizenship-by-Investment Programs

This ruling sends a clear message across Europe: citizenship-by-investment programs must not bypass the core values of the European Union. Cyprus (November 2020) and Bulgaria (April 2022) had already closed their schemes. Merit-based routes, such as Croatia’s special-interest citizenship, reward a real contribution rather than a payment, and Caribbean citizenship programmes sit outside EU law altogether.

What Happens to Existing Malta Golden Passport Holders?

It’s still unclear whether individuals who previously acquired citizenship through Malta’s scheme will be affected. Legal experts believe retroactive cancellation of citizenship is unlikely but that stricter vetting and reporting may be applied going forward.


Conclusion: A New Era for Investment-Based Citizenship in Europe

The declaration of the Malta golden passport as illegal goes beyond Malta. It shows that the EU will not accept citizenship sold for cash. That could reshape the future of residency and citizenship-by-investment programs, favouring residence routes built on genuine economic activity, such as France’s €300,000 direct-investment permit.

Related articles

Picture of Charlie Maggi

Charlie Maggi

Founder & CEO, The Open World, With over 20 years of expertise in global mobility, immigration, and international relocation, Charlie MAGGI specializes in visa, residency, and second citizenship solutions. He provides clear, compliant, and personalized guidance to individuals, families, and businesses worldwide. Committed to making cross-border transitions smooth, efficient, and secure.

Visit Author Profile
Picture of Charlie Maggi

Charlie Maggi

Founder & CEO, The Open World, With over 20 years of expertise in global mobility, immigration, and international relocation, Charlie MAGGI specializes in visa, residency, and second citizenship solutions. He provides clear, compliant, and personalized guidance to individuals, families, and businesses worldwide. Committed to making cross-border transitions smooth, efficient, and secure.

Visit Author Profile